Is it just me or have
you noticed that Facebook has completely sold out and is more and
more being used as a social network “selling tool”? And that it
is getting a little creepy? It used to be you only had to tolerate
advertising when watching a show on TV. Now you have to scroll
through cleverly engineered advertisements in order to communicate
with your friends or see their communications with you.
How ingenious to insert
advertising in the midst of your social conversation. Its like
standing around at a party, having a great conversation with ones
friends and then some guy walks up and says:
“I like Walmart! Save
More. Live Better, ”.
I actually saw a post a
few months ago that a friend who I know “likes” WalMart.
However, I do really
know this person, they despise WalMart and would not be caught dead
shopping there. That person obviously did not “like” Walmart. In my personal opinion
- to paraphrase rain man – Walmart Sucks. I
ignored this at the time as I did not really see the significance of
it. (Advertisement...scroll....scroll)
But this bit of
“advertising” must have grabbed a random person I am friends with
from Facebooks database – a popular person with lots of friends of
their own – and then said that they liked Walmart in a post
directed at me. Sort of like a celebrity endorsement but without
having to pay anything to the “celebrity”.
From a programmers
point of view this does not seem so hard. First pick out each user in
the database that lives in or around a WalMart location. For each
user select one of their friends, preferably a popular one with lots
of friends themselves. Customize the Walmart Advertisement to put
that friend as “liking” it. Post to that persons news feed.
Repeat a gazillion times...
Brilliant social
marketing? This seems more like blatant false advertising to me and
probably a few lawyers out there would agree if it ever gets to a
court of law. But who would you “punish”? Facebook for making
money from advertisers who employ this nifty technique or the
advertiser for actually saying someone likes them when it is obvious
they never liked them and even despise them?
How many people are
simply unaware that they are being used and manipulated by some large
corporation with deep enough pockets to pay Facebook for these
advertisements so they can make more money hawking their cheap goods
produced in China? Perhaps Facebook really thinks that no one
notices or maybe no one cares.
Oddly enough, as I was
writing this, I went over to Facebook.
Lo and behold, here is
a post from one of my friends on Facebook (I took out the names and
photos):
Doesn't this “social
marketing” for fun and profit overstep ethical boundaries of what
is acceptable? It is clearly intentionally deceptive and false.
It is clear, to me
anyway, that Facebook is intentionally using the information it has
stored on the friends that I have communicated with in my life and
then is using that social experiential data to make money for itself
and its advertisers who use this social marketing tactic. I know,
Facebook has user terms and conditions that I agree to by using it
and is free so I shouldn't complain when I am getting something free.
In fact, the social benefits of improved communication among the
vast amount of people who now use Facebook may well out-weigh the
minor inconvenience of ignoring these idiotic ads.
However, people should
at least know that enabling social communication with present and
past friends in their life turns out to not be entirely free.
Mark